United States Advance the Implementation of Clear Rules on Demurrage and Detention
United States Advance the Implementation of Clear Rules on Demurrage and Detention
Marta Borges
Lawyer, guest professor and PhD candidate
This year, the U.S. Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) adopted a new rule aimed at bringing greater transparency and clarity to the billing practices relating to demurrage and detention charges in the maritime sector.
Effective from 28 May 2024, this measure forms part of the Ocean Shipping Reform Act of 2022 and aims to clarify the charges associated with the storage and use of containers at maritime terminals, as well as the resulting demurrage and detention costs.
As of 29 May 2024, ocean carriers and marine terminal operators in the United States are required to include specific minimum information in their demurrage and detention invoices. This ensures greater transparency and enables the parties concerned to clearly understand the charges imposed and the entity responsible for levying them.
Among others, the following information is considered essential and must now be included in every invoice: (a) the date on which the container was made available; (b) the port of discharge; (c) the container number(s); (d) the commencement and expiry dates of the free time period; (e) the applicable demurrage or detention rules; (f) the applicable daily rate(s); (g) the total amount due; and (h) contact information for enquiries or requests for fee mitigation.
In addition, ocean carriers must issue a certification confirming compliance with the FMC rules and ensure that their own conduct did not contribute to the demurrage or detention charges imposed. The new regulation also specifies the parties that may be held liable for demurrage and detention charges and establishes clear deadlines for the issuance of invoices, the submission of claims and the resolution of disputes. It further provides that consignees may, in certain circumstances, be held liable for such charges and clarifies the timeframe within which Non-Vessel-Operating Common Carriers (NVOCCs) may recover those charges from their customers.
The new rule benefits the entire logistics chain by promoting greater transparency and fairness in the application of demurrage and detention charges. Although this regulation applies only in the United States, it has already prompted several ocean carriers to announce new practices for that market. Maersk, for example, announced on 18 July 2024 that it would update its demurrage and detention tariffs in the United States with effect from 8 August 2024. CMA CGM also published an update on its official website on 10 July 2024 to reflect compliance with the new rule, and other carriers are expected to follow suit.
Between 2020 and 2022, the nine largest ocean carriers operating on U.S. trade routes collected approximately USD 8.9 billion in demurrage and detention charges. This prompted the Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) to recognise the need for regulatory intervention to clarify the basis for such charges and ensure that shippers and consignees had a better understanding of these costs. Previously, in 2015, following numerous complaints from shippers, freight forwarders and logistics operators concerning the reduction of free time and the increase in demurrage and detention charges, the FMC issued its first report, highlighting the lack of consistency and transparency in the application of such charges by ocean carriers. Shippers and logistics operators called for clearer rules, leading to a second report in 2018, which acknowledged the importance of these charges as an incentive for the efficient movement of containerised cargo, while warning against their excessive and unjustified application. In May 2020, the FMC issued a Final Rule clarifying the interpretation of U.S. legislation governing demurrage and detention practices. This was subsequently complemented by the new Final Rule on Detention and Demurrage Billing Practices, which further develops and completes the earlier regulatory framework.
In Europe, there is no equivalent regulatory framework. Instead, the matter is governed by the contract of carriage by sea, based on the former International Convention...
for the Unification of Certain Rules of Law Relating to Bills of Lading, signed in Brussels, which marks its 100th anniversary on 25 August 2024. This Convention does not address this issue, leaving its regulation to national legislation. In Portugal, the matter is therefore governed by Decree-Law No. 352/86 of 21 October, which
is likewise silent as to the information that must be included in invoices issued by ocean carriers, leaving the matter to the applicable general legislation.
Even in the absence of a legal obligation, ocean carriers should adopt this practice globally in order to promote greater transparency in the market and reduce disputes arising from a lack of knowledge and information among the parties involved in the maritime logistics chain.
The U.S. Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) is an independent federal agency responsible for regulating the international ocean transportation system of the United States.
for the benefit of U.S. exporters, importers and consumers. Its primary mission is to promote a highly competitive and reliable international ocean transportation system that supports the U.S. economy and protects the American public from unfair and deceptive practices.
Article Published in APAT Journal, Issue No. 148 – July/August 2024
Consult in 49068C70-225D0_1.pdf (apat.pt)

